Vionic Carmela Black Suede Leather Perforated Pointed Toe Flats Shoes Womens 7 Vionic Carmela Black Suede Leather Perforated Pointed Toe Flats Shoes Womens 7. No stains, rips or tears. There is a scratch on the side of one shoe. Please see all photos for condition. I was not able to get the marker off of the bottoms. #BusinessCasual #Neutral #Leather #Office